Finding a renter who you can be sure is reliable starts with a thorough tenant screening process. For this, landlords need to pay attention to complying with legal requirements while reviewing background reports.
What is Tenant Screening?
This is the process a property owner may use to review and evaluate a prospective renter before approving a lease. Usually, this step involves information provided by the prospective renter in their application, along with your own verification and review of their tenant history. Many landlords use background checks and consumer reports in their review.
The goal of this screening process is to determine if a tenant applicant meets the unit’s rental criteria. This doesn’t mean you can use this process to look for the “perfect” renter. Instead, this review, along with written standards, can help landlords make decisions that they can easily defend or stand by.
The Fair Housing Act prohibits housing discrimination based on protected characteristics. Illinois also prohibits discriminatory application and screening practices. Chicago provides additional local fair housing protections, including protection based on source of income.
Benefits of Rental Property Tenant Screening Process
A tenant review shouldn’t be something landlords do recklessly or without structure. Having a defined process helps property owners assess whether they can trust an applicant to pay rent on time and comply with the lease. It also minimizes any temptation to make decisions based solely on first impressions.
Consistency, in this case, also remains important, especially if considering Illinois state law. The country’s legislation includes guidelines clarifying that property owners may verify a potential homeowner’s income and credit. However, it also stipulates that screening standards should be applied fairly.
When done this way, good tenant screening becomes both a risk management solution and a way to ensure legal compliance. This approach works well since it applies even before a tenant application is received.
The Tenant Screening Process for Chicago Landlords
Chicago landlords may take numerous steps in the tenant screening process. However, all these steps need to help you, as a landlord, decide whether to accept an application.
Here are some steps commonly involved in renter screening.
1. Establish Written Tenant Selection Criteria
The first thing you need to do is to identify your renter selection criteria in writing. Establish and define the characteristics you’re looking for in a renter.
Some standards you may want to consider include a person’s ability to pay rent and their rental history. You can also include occupancy requirements and other applicable lease-related factors.
One thing to remember is that you need to use the same standards across all tenant applicants in comparable situations. This means while you should stay consistent with applying the criteria, you may also need to consider special considerations for qualified individuals.
In Illinois, landlords are allowed to conduct reasonable income standards and credit reports under the Fair Credit Reporting Act. However, if you enforce standards inconsistently or discriminatorily, you may find yourself in violation of state law.
2. Disclose Required Information
Before even accepting a prospect’s application fee, you should provide them with all the needed information about your rental and arrangement. This would include the tenant selection criteria and a notice of the applicant’s rights regarding criminal history information. On top of that, property owners should also provide them with access to copies of specific local government ordinances that may apply or be used in the application.
On the other hand, when collecting information, a rental application should ask only for what is relevant to the screening process. It shouldn’t include questions that ask for sensitive or irrelevant information.
3. Complete the Noncriminal Screening First
The first stage is prequalification. At this point, landlords may evaluate the applicant under their ordinary rental standards, but they may not yet conduct a criminal background check.
This stage can include income verification and credit review. Landlords can also confirm rental history and contact references when appropriate. The key is to verify information rather than rely only on what appears on the application.
If the applicant does not satisfy the established noncriminal criteria, the landlord may deny the application at this stage. If the applicant does qualify, the process can move forward.
4. Conduct the Tenant Screening Background Check
Once an applicant is pre-qualified, that’s the only time when landlords can conduct a background check. This may involve criminal checks, but it’s not mandatory. However, for those who choose to do so, do make sure to follow the Just Housing Amendment.
Property owners conducting the screening need to keep in mind that they may not consider any criminal history older than 3 years. Denials also can’t be justified by arrest records without a conviction. For convictions within the past 3 years, landlords must conduct an individualized review before denying housing.
5. Approve or Deny the Application
Once applications have been reviewed and background checks have been completed, the landlord may approve or deny the application.
When doing so, you must use the same criteria you’ve used for other applicants, except for those with valid exemptions.
If you decide to deny an application, especially when the decision is based on a covered criminal conviction, it would help to provide an explanation that justifies the decision. The justification should demonstrate that the decision was necessary to address a risk in the situation.
Tenant Screening Checklist for Chicago Landlords
A tenant screening checklist can help owners follow the same procedure each time, rather than improvising from one application to the next.
- Write clear tenant selection criteria before advertising the rental property.
- Give applicants the required Cook County screening notices before accepting an application fee.
- Review noncriminal qualifications before asking for a criminal background report.
- Apply income and credit standards consistently, while respecting source-of-income protections.
- Keep records showing how the final decision matched the stated criteria.
- Send required adverse action or criminal-history denial notices promptly.
As a best practice, landlords and rental managers should review this checklist regularly. Screening laws and ordinances may change over time, so you will need to keep the process compliant.
A Consistent Process
Knowing how to screen tenants balances applicants’ rights and protections with efficient ways to find a responsible renter.
Westward360 Rental Management provides tenant screening services to multifamily properties, single-family and condo units, commercial establishments, and mixed-use developments in Chicago and beyond. Call us today at (773) 648-7244 or contact us online to get started!
Related Articles:



